James Robinson (page 3)

Justice League: Cry For Justice #1

Issue Credits

Writer
James Robinson
Artist
Mauro Cascioli
Letterer
Steve Wands
Associate Editor
Adam Schlagman
Editor
Eddie Berganza
Cover Artist
Mauro Cascioli

Synopsis "The Beginning"

JUSTICE LEAGUE: CRY FOR JUSTICE is the long awaited fully-painted JLA series by the new JLA writer James Robinson (STARMAN, SUPERMAN) and Mauro Cascoili (TRIALS OF SHAZAM). It was announced at last years Wizard World: LA as an ongoing title simply called JUSTICE LEAGUE that was to spin out of Grant Morrison’s FINAL CRISIS. However, it was cut back to a mini-series after it became clear that the painted artwork couldn’t be produced at a monthly pace. Events have conspired so that Robinson is still going to be doing a JLA ongoing, but first we have CRY FOR JUSTICE. It serves as a seven part mini-series that will set up Robinson’s run and it has also been hinted that it will set things up for next year in the DCU.

Spoiler… The guts of CRY FOR JUSTICE is pretty much what we’ve seen in the preview from DC Comics. Hal Jordan has a confrontation with the Justice League over their almost passive reaction to the murders of the Batman and the Martian Manhunter during FINAL CRISIS. This scene in particular takes place just before “Welcome to Sundown Town” the long Milestone/Starbreaker arc that’s just finished in the main Justice League title. Hal tells the League he’s going to take a stance against the supervillains, but his actual plans seem rather vague. Oliver Queen (Green Arrow) agrees to join him out of loyalty. Many years ago Hal joined Ollie for their “Hard Travelling Heroes” gig and Ollie is repaying the favour.

Elsewhere other heroes are confronted by the need for justice. Ray Palmer aided by Ryan Choi (the two Atoms) takes down the Killer Moth while searching for the stolen Time Pool. Palmer’s friend was tortured and killed for information about the Pool and he’s how hunting for Justice. In Opal City Mikaal Thomas, one of the more obscure claimants to the Starman codename, views the body of his dead boyfriend. He was killed in a supervillain attack on New York’s STAR Labs and Mikaal now wants Justice. In the Congo, the troop of gorillas that were Congorilla‘s family have been slaughtered. The local hero Freedom Beast and Congo Bill’s original body also died in the attack. Now Bill is trapped in Congorilla’s body and wants Justice.

The theme of the first issue is heroes individually wanting justice for some horrible crime or other committed against somebody they love. The supervillain Prometheus is name checked in the Atom scene and that feeds back into last year’s FACES OF EVIL: PROMETHEUS special by Sterling Gates so it’s fairly clear who the badguy is. How much his plans link the heroes individual pains isn’t clear.

We don’t see the entire team this issue, Supergirl, Batwoman, and Freddy Freeman don’t appear.  There is also a six-page text feature at the back where James Robinson introduces some background to the more obscure characters and explains some of his thinking. It seems we’ll be getting more text pieces in later issues. Lastly there is a brand new two-page secret origin of Congo Bill written by Len Wein (JLA #35-38) with art by Ardian Syaf (JLA #34).

The painted art by Mauro Cascoili in the main story is fantastic. For a 22-page story we sure seem to have seen a lot of these pages before – either as sneak peaks or as the main 8-page preview. It’s good to get the audience’s attention, but leaves the danger of showing too much too soon. I particularly liked the Opal City skyline at night and the blood red skies of the Congo at twilight. I don’t think a gorilla has ever looked quite so good in a comicbook.

Overall I quite liked the issue, but it didn’t really go anywhere. It was all about establishing the heroes and where they’re coming from. The plot should get more interesting once the group starts meeting each other.

The Verdict

TypeSiteReviewerOriginal ScoreEquivalent
Grand Average 68.1%
Reviews Portal Comic Book Resources Doug Zawisza 4/5
Reviews Portal Comics Bulletin Erik Norris 4.5/5
Reviews Portal IGN Dan Philips 5.2/10
Community Reviews Comics Vine User Reviews Av. of 5 reviews 3.2/5
Community Reviews iFanboy 584 Pulls 3.8/5
Character Site Supergirl Comic Book Commentary Anj B+/B
Character Site Superman Homepage Michael Bailey 5 (story) & 5 (art)/5
Reviews Blog A Comic Book Blog Wayland 3.5/5
Reviews Blog Comics Per Day Reviews Timbotron Poor
Reviews Blog Inside Pulse Joel La Puma /10
Character Site Captain's Justice League Homepage Jason Kirk 4/5

Characters

The list of characters that appear in this series is quite large and changes as the series goes on. However, for reference to the original publicity materials, I’ve taken the list of featured characters as those heroes who appeared on the double-cover to the first issue.

Feature Characters

  • Atom (Ray Palmer. Violently interrogates Killer Moth to find out why he murdered Mike Dante. Declares that he wants “Justice” for Mike. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)
  • Congorilla (William (Congo Bill) Glenmorgan in the body of the Great Golden Gorilla. His human body and the mind of the Golden Gorilla die this issue leaving Bill trapped in Congorilla’s body. Cries “Justice” for the murder of the gorilla troop he had been living with. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)
  • Green Arrow (Oliver Queen. Tagging along with Hal Jordan’s crusade for the sake of their friendship. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)
  • Green Lantern (Hal Jordan. Calls a meeting of the Justice League to declare his intention to found a more aggressive breakaway group. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)
  • Starman (Mikal Tomas. Opal City’s protector, visits his boyfriend’s body at the undertakers. Cries “Justice” for Tony’s murder. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)
  • Supergirl (Kara Zor-El. Superman’s cousin. Hears Hal’s argument at the JLA meeting. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)

Guest Stars

  • Atom IV (Ryan Choi. He helps Ray Palmer hunt down and interrogate the Killer Moth after the murder of Mike Dante. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Generation Lost #1.)
  • Freedom Beast (Dominic Mnawe, the successor to B’wana Beast. Killed by the villains while they were hunting for the Gorilla City scientist Malavar. He was an old friend of Congo Bill. First and only indexed appearance.)

Villains

  • Prometheus (Behind-the-scenes. Mentioned by Killer Moth as being his employer in the Time Pool theft. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #2.)
  • Killer Moth (Earth-Zero) (In the old costume. He killed Mike Dante, a friend of Ray Palmer, whilst stealing the Time Pool. Palmer finds him and forces him to reveal that the theft was arranged by Prometheus. First and only indexed appearance.)
  • Henchmen (Killer Moth’s Henchmen. Beaten by Atom II and Atom IV. First and only indexed appearance.)

Guest Appearances

Other Characters

  • Congorilla’s Troop (A troop of gorillas. Slaughtered by the villains whilst they were looking for the Gorilla City scientist Malavar. First and only indexed appearance.)
  • Opal City Undertaker (Looking after Tony’s funeral. First and only indexed appearance.)
  • Tony (Mikal Tomas’s boyfriend. Killed off-screen during a super-villain attack on STAR Labs in Metropolis. First and only indexed appearance.)

Cameo Appearances

  • Jake ‘Bobo’ Benetti (Mentioned as helping Mikal make arrangement for his boyfriend’s funeral. First and only indexed appearance.)
  • Mike Dante (Professor Hyatt’s former assistant. Killed by the Killer Moth whilst he was searching for the Time Pool. First and only indexed appearance.)
  • Professor Hyatt (The inventor of the Time Pool. A friend of Ray Palmer. Its mentioned that his memory isn’t what it was. First and only indexed appearance.)

Flashback

  • Batman (Bruce Wayne. One panel flashback to his “death” during the Final Crisis. First indexed appearance. Next indexed appearance is Justice League: Cry For Justice #3.)
  • Martian Manhunter (J’onn J’onzz. One panel flashback to his murder in the Final Crisis. First and only indexed appearance.)

JLA writers: JLA #34 preview @ Newsarama & Robinson interview at CBR

The change over from Dwayne McDuffie, through Len Wein, to James Robinson continues apace. Newsarama have a preview of JLA #34 and it appears that the credits confusion continues where both JLA #34 and JLA #35 are listed as the first part of Len Wein’s run. Their description in Newsarama’s preview states that:

Len Wein takes over the pages of Justice League in the first of a two-part story featuring Starbreaker.

JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA
Written by Len Wein; Art by Jose Luis and JP Mayer; Cover by Ed Benes and Rob Hunter

However, the credits box in the actual preview itself clearly shows:

JLA #34 credits

I really hope this continued misattribution of the credits isn’t some slight towards the departing writer.

Nevertheless, Len Wein takes over from JLA #35 for his three-part Royal Flush Gang story. That was originally a two-parter, but like a tall tale it seems to be getting longer at each telling. CBR has an interview with James Robinson about joining the JLA and they note that Wein’s run will be four-issues.

Unsurprisingly James Robinson’s interview is noncomital on details of his run, but he does comment on the transition from CRY FOR JUSTICE to the main JLA title

“I was very happy to be writing ‘Superman’ and being a part of the Superman team, but when the offer came up and they asked whether I was interested in writing ‘Justice League of America,’ I realized how exciting it would be to fold what happens in ‘Cry for Justice’ into the ‘Justice League’ book and sort of continue on from there,” explained Robinson.

[...]

“What I’m doing is basically picking up where Len Wein left off, getting the team through the traumatic, incredibly exciting but obviously traumatic events of ‘Blackest Night’ and then from that I’m going to build a new team comprising of some big names from the DC Universe and… well, pretty much, a lot of big names from the DC Universe,” Robinson confirmed.

When asked if there would be any holdovers from “Cry for Justice,” Robinson confirmed, “Absolutely. It won’t be the exact same team but half of the team will be going into the new book. I’ll leave it at that.”

I was also interested in a comment towards the end of the interview

But from where I started on ‘Superman,’ I think the book’s got better and better, personally. I’m quite proud of that but with ‘Justice League of America,’ I think I am now more immersed in the lore of the DC Universe. The chains of communication between myself and the Superman writers and Geoff Johns and editors Eddie Berganza and Matt Idelson and Ian Sattler and Dan DiDio are much clearer and we’re moving forward, all of us together, in a very clear direction.

It is arguably that its poor “chains of communication” that led to Dwayne’s furstration with writing JLA and his ultimate removal from the title. Hopefully, James’s comments means that this problem is delibrately being addressed. We’ll find out in October.

New JLA creative team: Robinson and Bagley

In hindsight it was a fairly obvious move. Once Dwayne McDuffie was fired from JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA there was of course still one other writer at DC who was working on a JLA book. James Robinson’s CRY OF JUSTICE mini-series was originally to have been on ongoing project, but was turned into a limited series. Now DC’s The Source has announced that Robinson will be taking over the main ongoing JLA title.

“It’s a thrill to be given the reins of DC’s flagship team book and to know that my partner in crime(fighting) will be the esteemed Mark Bagley who’s dynamic storytelling skills I intend to make full use of.  It’s further exciting/gratifying for me that I can dove-tail the events of Cry For Justice into the main book where post-Blackest Night will emerge a new team and a new exciting direction as they get caught up in the next wave of events building throughout the DCU.”

It’ll be interesting to see how Robinson preforms, but he’s no stranger to Justice League teams. Least we forget that it was James Robinson who created a version of Justice League Europe in STARMAN just so he could have them all assassinated by the Mist. Hopefully the Leaguers left over from McDuffie’s run will avoid that fate.

Joining James Robinson with be Mark Bagley who moved from Marvel to work on DC’s weekly TRINITY title. Kurt Busiek’s scripts gave Mark almost every single character in the DC Universe to draw so a JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA should be quite relaxing for him. In a recent CBR interview he noted that,

I occasionally wanted to strangle Kurt [Busiek] when I’d get the [Trinity] plots involving the entire DC Universe. I wish I could have been faster so [inker] Art Thibert and [Colourist] Pete Pantazis would have had more time to do their jobs. They are both terrific, but I know we were all a bit compromised by the speed we had to work. Also I wish Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman had been in their “normal” forms for more of the story but that wasn’t what the story dictated.

Well it now look’s like he’ll get his chance with Justice League – providing DC can actually let Robinson and Bagley have the big guns back.

James Robinson interview @ CBR

CBR have an interview with James Robinson, writer of Justice League: Cry for Justice. The series was originally announced as an ongoing project, but was later re-announced as a mini-series partially based on the speed of the artist.

And I’m glad that it’s ultimately a six-issue miniseries because I think it makes it more special and unique. The art is gorgeous. The guy is amazing. It’s so exciting to see the painted pages when they come in. And the thing about a lot of miniseries is that they might as well be Elseworlds. They have no repercussions to the big picture. No matter how good they are. That’s goes for graphic novels too. Very few of them have any resonance beyond the story that they are in. Whereas with this one, it’s a gigantic ending, bigger than you can possibly imagine, it’s something that will have a ripple effect on the Justice League and to a degree the DC Universe for quite some time.

Each page is fully painted by Mauro Cascioli and it is obviously not a fast process. Casciolio succeeded Howard Porter as the painter on Trials of Shazam after Porter was forced to withdrawl due to health grounds.

In another comment, Robinson doesn’t pull his punches for the poor old Atom:

At the moment, I defy anybody to tell me what is Ray Palmer’s personality? He’s the most unlucky-in-love guy ever. And that’s about it really. So we have a little bit more of a sense of who he is. And how far he’ll go for Justice and that sort of thing. It will make him more of a compelling character.